thanksgiving at magpies

to peruse this year’s menu, pre-order your treats, and find answers to all your Turkey Day pie questions, keep scrolling!

important info

  • Pre-order your Thanksgiving pies in advance (below), and pick them up on WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER 26th at one of two locations:

-MAGPIES (1051 Back River Rd. DeLancey, NY) from 10am-2pm (cafe will be open if you need fuel for your holiday errands!)

-MONTGOMERY PLACE ORCHARDS (4283 Rt 9G Red Hook, NY) from 10am-1pm

****Please select pick-up location during online check-out! (if using Apple Pay from your phone, continue scrolling to below where you verify name and billing to find the “method” box, and click that for pick-up options) ****

  • All pie orders MUST BE PLACED BY FRIDAY NOVEMBER 21ST AT MIDNIGHT.

  • Due to the limited kitchen space and high volume of the holiday, no dietary restrictions or special requests will be possible to accommodate at this time.

  • There will be a handful of extra pies at both locations for last-minute needs, but preordering is strongly encouraged to guarantee you’ve got what you need on your Thanksgiving table:)

  • For any questions or issues, please email magpiesonpinkstreet@gmail.com

*I’m proud to rely on the best our home and farmers have to offer, and local ingredients like eggs, cream, apples, maple syrup, and honey make these pies truly Catskills-special. Thank you for supporting all of us producers here in Delaware County!

Thanksgiving!